Scientific Revolution
Science is old and new, at the same time.
Ancient History
NEXT IN "OUR ANSWERS" SERIES: (Impasse: Why Science Rejects Paranormal)
9. Echo Chambers - OUR ANSWER
QUICK LINKS - Impasse: Why Science Rejects Paranormal
MAIN / Why Science Rejects the Paranormal
MAIN / OUR ANSWER 1. Start Here - Short Answer
MAIN / OUR ANSWER 2. Scientific Revolution
MAIN / OUR ANSWER 3. Misunderstanding Science
MAIN / OUR ANSWER 4. Paranormal Rejects Science
MAIN / OUR ANSWER 5. Hoaxes
MAIN / OUR ANSWER 6. Failed Studies
MAIN / OUR ANSWER 7. The Amazing Randi
MAIN / OUR ANSWER 8. Bad Science
MAIN / OUR ANSWER 9. Echo Chambers
MAIN / What's Your Opinion?
Home
NOTE: The material in the APP's "Our Answers" sometimes seems elementary and simplistic, yet at the same time long and drawn-out. Yes. It's the beginning foundation for the topic. If you're an expert on a topic, then by all means add your suggestions to the appropriate forums. There can be a steep learning curve for those not already familiar with the many facets (and topics) covered by this project. Our answers are a starting point. (Feel free to help round-out topics if we've missed something.)
If you're in-between a novice and an expert, consider just checking out the several RESOURCES listed within each of our "OUR ANSWERS" posts. Readers don't have to take our word for it. Each part has good external sources/links, so you can get more in-depth and intricate answers from real experts. Remember when you see Wikipedia listed, that it has a ton of references so you can see where the information originated. Wiki is also great for an overview of a subject. And on big topics there's usually a system of organization that gives each facet its own flowchart of information/sources. (And Wiki is free, with no ads, and open to peer review. What's not to like?)
DISCUSSION & FEEDBACK
Share your knowledge. Don't be shy if you have a QUALITY contribution. (But please be polite, and proofread.) Sometimes special forums exist just for feedback on the project. That'll be apparent when looking at the list of a forum's discussions.
There are two ways to add your opinions/content: Either create a reply OR create a new post.
For a quick comment about whatever post you're reading, just REPLY to it. The button is available both above and below the post, and has BRIGHT PURPLE text.
To add a new post of your own to a discussion, use the "NEW TOPIC" button located on every forum's main list of posts. Generally hit the back button from any post you're reading (or use the breadcrumbs up top), to go back a step to the main forum for that discussion. The button is available both above and below every forum's main list of posts, has BRIGHT PURPLE text, and says "NEW TOPIC." (It sounds more formal than it is.)
If you have a nice chunk of GOOD INFORMATION, please choose to add a NEW post in the (most-) appropriate forum rather than a comment-reply. That way you'll generate comments of your own. PLUS it will show up in the list of posts so other interested people will notice it's there. (PLUS we're a new website/project, so we could use all the QUALITY submissions we can get.)
All of your content displays your avatar and tagline (signature). You can edit these in your "user panel" or it will default to generic/blank. BTW, users can include plugs to their own websites or whatever, in their profiles. USERS BEWARE and Google the website name before you actually go there. Make sure you're going to some place legit that isn't going to scam you or give your computer an STD. (Little joke there. I'll see myself out...)
TIPS FOR POLLS: Polls appear on some posts, IF its author has created one. They're open to ALL registered users. All APP-written polls are set to be ongoing and allow you to change your vote later. Feel free to comment your suggestions for improving any poll, ours or others', just be kind and helpful.
CREATING A POLL: When writing any post (not comment replies) look for the option named "Poll Creation" in a TAB below the "submit" button. Fill in your Qs/As and double-check the default options. You can always edit the poll later via editing the POST itself and navigating back to that same tab. (Change whatever and re-submit.) But that sort of defeats the purpose if you change it after people have answered, right? So to start, create an option for ALL POSSIBLE points of view. Lastly, the poll will display below the post after it's published. In "preview" mode it shows on top.
.
.
It is currently Sat Nov 23, 2024 3:01 am
8. Bad Science - Our Answer
Paranormal researchers don't like to measure, yet for empirical science you have to measure it, for it to count.
Jump to
- ↳ Ante Up
- ↳ Ante Up
- Welcome
- ↳ Welcome to The Aster-P Project!
- Deliverables
- ↳ APP Deliverables
- ↳ Study #1 (recent paranormal claims)
- ↳ FEEDBACK - About Study #1
- ↳ FEEDBACK - ALL STUDY MATERIALS, Full paper and sources download
- ↳ FEEDBACK - Front Matter
- ↳ FEEDBACK - Abstract & Significance
- ↳ FEEDBACK - Introduction
- ↳ FEEDBACK - Method
- ↳ FEEDBACK - Results and Discussion
- ↳ FEEDBACK - Conclusion
- ↳ FEEDBACK - References
- ↳ FEEDBACK - Appendix 1 - All Tables
- ↳ FEEDBACK - Appendix 2 - Fear Reports, Isolated
- ↳ FEEDBACK - Appendix 3 - Measurable Reports Examination
- ↳ FEEDBACK - Appendix 4 - Remarkable Reports Examination
- ↳ FEEDBACK - Appendix 5 - All Reports, All Variables
- ↳ FEEDBACK - Appendix 6 - Draft Outreach Plan
- ↳ FEEDBACK - Acknowledgements
- ↳ Miscellaneous Feedback
- ↳ Study #2 (directed public survey)
- ↳ Study #3 (post review)
- ↳ Study #4 (best claims)
- ↳ Practical Field-Guide Book #1
- ↳ Prototype: PS APParatus
- ↳ Study #5 (TBA)
- The Impasse
- ↳ Why Science Rejects the Paranormal
- ↳ 1. SHORT ANSWER
- ↳ 2. Scientific Revolution
- ↳ 3. Misunderstanding Science
- ↳ 4. Paranormal Rejects Science
- ↳ 5. Hoaxes
- ↳ 6. Failed Studies
- ↳ 7. The Amazing Randi
- ↳ 8. Bad Science
- ↳ 9. Echo Chambers
- ↳ What's Your Opinion?
- ↳ Can the Paranormal Be Proven?
- ↳ Good Science
- ↳ 1. SHORT ANSWER
- ↳ 2. Critical Thinking
- ↳ 3. CT - Next Level
- ↳ 4. Vet Your Sources
- ↳ 5. "Do Your Own Research"
- ↳ 6. Methodology is Key
- ↳ 7. The Scientific Method
- ↳ 8. Replication - Or it Didn't Happen
- ↳ 9. Peer Review Can Be Brutal
- ↳ 10. Journals
- ↳ What's Your Opinion?
- Debunking Help
- ↳ Debunking - Self Help
- ↳ 1. Start Here
- ↳ 2. Air Quality
- ↳ 3. Infrasound
- ↳ 4. EMF
- ↳ 5. Drafts
- ↳ 6. Home Surveillance Systems
- ↳ 7. Movement
- ↳ 8. Psychology
- ↳ 9. Shadows
- ↳ 10. When Self-Debunking Fails
- ↳ Measuring Equipment
- Methodology - Theoretical
- ↳ Scientific Methodology Forums and *Panels*
- ↳ Methodology About
- ↳ About the Methodology Forums
- ↳ About the Methodology *Panels*
- ↳ Methodology APP Studies
- ↳ APPMF#3 - Study #1
- ↳ APPMF#4 - Study #2
- ↳ Methodology - Debunking - How to Measure
- ↳ MF#1 - What Components (normal thresholds) Affect a Micro-Environment?
- ↳ MF#2 - General Guidelines for Solving "Unknown" Events
- ↳ MF#3 - How to Evaluate Indoors - Visual Events
- ↳ MF#4 - How to Evaluate Indoors - Audio Events
- ↳ MF#5 - How to Evaluate Indoors - Moved Objects
- ↳ MF#6 - How to Evaluate Indoors - Body Feelings - Physical or Emotional
- ↳ MF#7 - How to Evaluate Indoors - Menacing Creatures
- ↳ MF#8 - How to Evaluate Indoors - Distressed babies and animals
- ↳ MF#9 - Sleep Disturbances / Sleep Paralysis
- ↳ MF#10 - Less Common: Video Call and Voice Mail Anomalies
- ↳ MF#11 - How to Evaluate Psychic Matters
- ↳ MF#12 - How to Evaluate Outdoors - Cryptids
- ↳ MF#13 - How to Evaluate Outdoors - UFOs and Abductions
- ↳ MF#14 - Electrical Disturbances / SLI
- ↳ Methodology *Panels*
- ↳ Panel#1 - Best Paranormal Claims Review
- ↳ Panel#2 - Past Claims Review Panel
- ↳ Panel#3 - Engineering the **PS APParatus**
- ↳ Panel #4 - Informal Claims Crew
- ↳ Methodology APP Effectiveness
- ↳ APPMF#1 - Peer Review: APP Effectiveness
- ↳ APPMF#2 - Biggest Obstacle to APP's Objective?
- ↳ Methodology APP Courses
- ↳ APP Courses
- ↳ About APP Courses
- ↳ APP-102
- ↳ APP-105
- ↳ APP-202
- ↳ APP-205
- ↳ APP-301
- ↳ APP-305
- Methodology - In Field
- ↳ In-Field Investigators' General Discussion
- ↳ About Investigator Methodology
- ↳ What Do You Need or Want?
- ↳ Biggest Obstacles to Evidence
- ↳ Anything Withstand Debunking?
- ↳ Best Case Methodology for Re-Testing
- ↳ Compare Best Practices
- ↳ Specializing
- ↳ Questions for Skeptics
- ↳ What's Your Opinion?
- ↳ In-Field Investigators' Methodology
- ↳ Blue Print for Methodology
- ↳ Parameters for Measuring Indoors
- ↳ Parameters for Measuring Outdoors
- ↳ Skeptical Certification
- Best Claims
- ↳ Best Paranormal Claims Review
- ↳ Details of the Case
- ↳ UPDATE
- ↳ The Take-Away
- Paranormal Library
- ↳ Paranormal Library - Categories
- ↳ START HERE!
- ↳ Abductions
- ↳ ANECDOTES: Abductions
- ↳ EXPERTS: Abductions
- ↳ Animal Related
- ↳ ANECDOTES: Animal
- ↳ EXPERTS: Animal
- ↳ Black-Eyed-Kids
- ↳ Anecdotes: Black-Eyed-Kids
- ↳ Experts: Black-Eyed-Kids
- ↳ Crop Circles
- ↳ Anecdotes: Crop Circles
- ↳ Experts: Crop Circles
- ↳ Cryptid
- ↳ ANECDOTES: Cryptid
- ↳ EXPERTS: Cryptid
- ↳ Dreams - After Life
- ↳ ANECDOTES: Dreams - AL
- ↳ EXPERTS: Dreams - AL
- ↳ Dreams - Astral Projection
- ↳ ANECDOTES: Dreams - AP
- ↳ EXPERTS: Dreams - AP
- ↳ Dreams - Premonitions
- ↳ ANECDOTES: Dreams - Prem
- ↳ EXPERTS: Dreams - Prem
- ↳ Doppelgangers
- ↳ ANECDOTES: Doppelgangers
- ↳ EXPERTS: Doppelgangers
- ↳ Electrical Disturbances / SLI
- ↳ ANECDOTES: Electrical Disturbances
- ↳ EXPERTS: Electrical Disturbances
- ↳ Elementals
- ↳ Anecdotes: Elementals
- ↳ Experts: Elementals
- ↳ ESP
- ↳ ANECDOTES: ESP
- ↳ EXPERTS: ESP
- ↳ Glitch in Matrix
- ↳ ANECDOTES: GIM
- ↳ EXPERTS: GIM
- ↳ Mediums
- ↳ ANECDOTES: Mediums
- ↳ EXPERTS: Mediums
- ↳ Men in Black
- ↳ Anecdotes: Men in Black
- ↳ Experts: Men in Black
- ↳ Missing 411
- ↳ ANECDOTES: Missing 411
- ↳ EXPERTS: Missing 411
- ↳ Moved Objects
- ↳ Anecdotes: Moved Objects
- ↳ Experts: Moved Objects
- ↳ Movement
- ↳ ANECDOTES: Movement
- ↳ EXPERTS: Movement
- ↳ Reincarnation
- ↳ Anecdotes: Reincarnation
- ↳ Shadows
- ↳ ANECDOTES: Shadows
- ↳ EXPERTS: Shadows
- ↳ Spirits - Harmless
- ↳ ANECDOTES: Spirits - Harmless
- ↳ EXPERTS: Spirits - Harmless
- ↳ Spirits - Malevolent
- ↳ ANECDOTES: Spirits - Malevolent
- ↳ EXPERTS: Spirits - Malevolent
- ↳ Time Travel
- ↳ ANECDOTES: Time Travel
- ↳ EXPERTS: Time Travel
- ↳ UFO
- ↳ ANECDOTES: UFO
- ↳ EXPERTS: UFO
- ↳ ** Suggest a Category
- Journal-ing
- ↳ APP Journal-ing
- Goofing Off
- ↳ Goofing Off
- ↳ Best "People" Performances
- ↳ Best Musical Performances
- ↳ Free, no-BS games
- ↳ Best of the Internet - Memes and EXCEPTIONALLY Cool Pics
- ↳ Oddly Satisfying
- ↳ Knock-Knock (Dad Jokes)
- ↳ Jokes - You Laugh You Lose (NSFW)
- General Discussion
- ↳ General Discussion Forums
- ↳ Current Problem?
- ↳ Past Problem?
- ↳ Skeptic Vent
- ↳ Suggestions for The Project
- ↳ Off Topic